Privacy Fencing - Vinyl Fence?

Nifty

Super Self-Sufficient
Administrator
Joined
Nov 13, 2007
Messages
1,351
Reaction score
128
Points
227
We need a 6' tall privacy fence that is about 12 - 16 feet long.

I was going to just build a wood one, but my GF likes the idea of a vinyl fence.

I found these "cheap" ones:
Home Depot:

Lowes:

Or we can go really fancy with a composite:

... but she's leaning towards vinyl.

Anybody have experience with vinyl privacy fences?
 

Britesea

Sustainability Master
Joined
Jul 22, 2011
Messages
5,118
Reaction score
4,032
Points
363
Location
Klamath County, OR
the vinyl one costs a LOT less... that would mean a lot to me when we're talking about 12-16 feet.
 

Lazy Gardener

Super Self-Sufficient
Joined
May 14, 2017
Messages
3,459
Reaction score
3,538
Points
262
Location
Central Maine, Zone 4B
I have experience with the white vinyl fencing... but not in the way you would expect. Last fall, we found a whole pallet of vinyl fencing. Components to make about (11) 6'H x 8'L panels. I bought the whole thing for $99!!!!! I've used some of it to make raised beds. I used Shou Sugi Ban treated cedar 2 x 4's to make corner posts, as well as placing them every 3 - 4' along the length to keep the plastic from bowing out. For a fence that has no structural stresses, I expect the vinyl would last a good long time. The installation will only be as good as the support that you give it.
 

Nifty

Super Self-Sufficient
Administrator
Joined
Nov 13, 2007
Messages
1,351
Reaction score
128
Points
227
Wow, what a find @Lazy Gardener !! That sounds like a gold-mine!

Do you know which brand of fencing it was? We're worried because some of the fences we've seen look really thin, brittle, or otherwise like they aren't very durable.
 

Nifty

Super Self-Sufficient
Administrator
Joined
Nov 13, 2007
Messages
1,351
Reaction score
128
Points
227
That's great, thanks!
 

flowerbug

Almost Self-Reliant
Joined
Oct 24, 2019
Messages
1,451
Reaction score
1,425
Points
187
Location
mid-Michigan, USoA
how long does it need to last?

i also am rather leery of anything plastic as eventually it seems the sun degrades it and it gets brittle or starts to crack or bend. the neighbors had some siding on their house that was so thin that it was damaged by hail. yes, it was a cheap manufactured house to begin with, but still you'd think at least it would have been required to be a certain rating for such things like hail.

my other issue with white is that eventually it may get some mildew on it which needs to be cleaned. a bit of bleach can sometimes do that without needing any kind of scrubbing or there are other cleaners which work too.

other than these thoughts, i have no other experience with privacy fencing other than wood.
 

Nifty

Super Self-Sufficient
Administrator
Joined
Nov 13, 2007
Messages
1,351
Reaction score
128
Points
227
how long does it need to last?

i also am rather leery of anything plastic as eventually it seems the sun degrades it and it gets brittle or starts to crack or bend. the neighbors had some siding on their house that was so thin that it was damaged by hail. yes, it was a cheap manufactured house to begin with, but still you'd think at least it would have been required to be a certain rating for such things like hail.

my other issue with white is that eventually it may get some mildew on it which needs to be cleaned. a bit of bleach can sometimes do that without needing any kind of scrubbing or there are other cleaners which work too.

other than these thoughts, i have no other experience with privacy fencing other than wood.
Great stuff! You make a lot of points I've been wondering about!

I don't need it to last forever, but I'd like it to last a while... at least as long as a moderately similar wood fence.

I've definitely seen the old ones that are thin and brittle... that said, I've also seen old wood fences in terrible shape, so I'm wondering if there's an apples to apples comparison on what each one looks like after 5, 10, 20 years.

I've also seen the vinyl fence with mildew / algae / fungus (or whatever green stuff) growing on them... and it stands out like a sore thumb on white plastic... but, I've also seen a lot of wood fences with similar junk on them, dry rot, bug holes, etc.

My GF is hoping it will be easier to maintain (no staining / painting) and clean (using power washer) than wood, but I'm also worried about longevity, brittleness, etc. My hope would be that they've improved the UV protection, etc. with the newer formulations of plastic?
 

FarmerJamie

Mr. Sensitive
Joined
Dec 22, 2010
Messages
6,009
Reaction score
2,109
Points
363
Like everything "it depends".

My personal experience with the former neighbor's fence. It was in a rather open area. Warped in extremely high heat one week and did not handle high winds from a thunderstorm
 

baymule

Sustainability Master
Joined
Nov 13, 2010
Messages
7,227
Reaction score
6,997
Points
363
Location
East Texas
Vinyl fencing is popular with horse people that have deep pockets. It usually looks pretty good. If it is priced comparable to wood fence and will last as long, then why not get the vinyl?
 
Top