I need to get something out - before I scream....and I'm trying to decide what's the right thing to do, ignore or warn people?
Here is where I talked about trading my BCM chicks for some BLRW - and in a post one page back I had commented that I almost didn't make the trade....
http://www.sufficientself.com/forum/viewtopic.php?id=717&p=368
The reason I almost didn't make the trade, is because the BLRW were advertised to be 20 weeks old - almost laying age. They were on the small side for supposedly 20 weeks old....I felt that they were more along the size of 10 week old chicks.
To put it into perspective, I got 5 chickerdoodles at 19 weeks of age from Keljonma, and they were the size of my full grown chickens!
The lady insisted that the BLRW were December's chicks, ordered from Blue Poultry. (Blue Poultry's birds are a cross of Foley's and Paul's BLRW)
Anyway, the woman gave us a tour of her chicken area, and was pretty much bending over backwards to make me happy because she really wanted those BCM chicks.
She also sold some Welsummer and Wheaten Marans to Becca - and the Welsummers didn't turn out looking like any Welsummers I'd ever seen.
Her breed pens were small cages, and the birds had pretty much just enough room to eat, drink, and lay an egg. They were cages the size of dog crates - cages that I would consider housing maybe a pair of bantams, but never LF. And they were stacked one on top of the other.
Most of the cages had either a pair of birds, or a trio. She then had this HUGE barn room with enclosed run that housed all the younger birds she had growing out.
I made the trade, more out of what I felt was the proper thing to do since Becca HAD drove me down there and it was nearly a 3 hour trip one way.
Anyway, now the reason I'm bringing this up? she's now on BYC. She has a listing up for her French Wheaten Marans and says, "My roo with his favorite hen". I've SEEN those birds - they live 24/7 in the cage that she took their picture in and favorite hen my FOOT! It's her ONLY hen!!! (not counting the young just hatched ones she was raising up - it's the only hen of laying age right now). She's selling 8+ eggs, so that means the OLDEST egg a person will get from her will be at least 8 days old. Plus, and I need to do some research into this, her roo has white earlobes - and I thought brown egg layers wouldn't have white earlobes???? but I'm not that up on all the Marans standards......
Normally I would mind my own business, and not feel like anything should be said, but she posted this long winded thing (to which I replied) in the Crazy Egg Chain Chat thread giving everyone a lecture NOT to ship old eggs..... and because I have had dealings with her and have seen things in person, I strongly feel that she's a little less than a reputable breeder - or to give her benefit of the doubt, she was severely duped by whomever sold her the birds she has.
The expensive "breeder" feed she claims to feed her birds - it's turkey feed! When we were down there, and I commented on the small size of her 20 week old birds, she told us she feeds turkey feed to all her birds because it's supposed to be better for them, make them grow faster, etc. etc.
She also had 7 month old BLRW's in a breeder cage, and they were so small, I asked her if they were bantams. She said NO!

I have a hard time keeping my mouth shut, and my instinctive reply was, "There's no way they are 7 months old then, because my LF BLRW are waaaaaaaaaay bigger than that! and they're 2 years old." I don't remember what her reply was, but I was so sick to my stomach, and couldn't wait to leave, and I know poor Becca was worried we'd made the trip and I was going to change my mind.
But, I made the trade, and we left, and I struggled with guilt over leaving those BCM's to who knows what kind of care. Yes, I know, it's just chickens.
So now she's selling on BYC, and I feel like she's being less than honest - and I don't want to call her out on the forums.
She was not very helpful at all when she was told that the Welsummer chicks she sold were nothing but mutts. She insisted they were pures, but they definitely DID NOT resemble Wellies - in fact, one actually resembled a BLRW AND had a rose comb!

Even after explaining that it had a rose comb, etc, she insisted that she had no young BLRW in the brooder with the Marans and Welsummers, and that she "showed us the parents, and both parents were definitely Welsummers".
The BLRW I got from her are beautiful. They're finally filling out, have doubled their size (except one hen, who's growth seems to be stunted), and they are starting to get red combs. Personally, I think either they didn't get enough nutrition before I got them, or they were so small because they were NOT as old as she says.
Anyway, I just had to get it out. It's driving me nuts every time I see her post more eggs for sale, or try to trade eggs - and I just needed to get it out before I exploded.
< end rant >