Replace fridge door seal?

[Hinotori]

This does look like the weather stripping.

However, I'd actually put "freezer door gasket" and the size you need. Might find something for under $100.

 

[flowerbug]

It had been patched with a foam ear plug for years.

i should have also made it clear that you want two layers of wax paper (one layer on each side that is gooped).