Before I post a little rant, I'd just like to express some confusion over the discussion of the candidates here. Can't we agree that McCain, Obama, Ron Paul, Ralph Nader, and the other presidential wanna-be people ALL want what's best for our country? You may think some or all of them are very wrong about what's best, as I'm sure we all do, but I think it's pretty clear that they all just want to make our country a great place. They just have different ideas on how to do it. So all this "prophesy of the end of the world" and "lies and deceit" and "destroy America" stuff just really bothers me. You might not like someone's ideas for helping our nation out, but do we really think they're trying to ruin our nation by being President? Seriously??
But getting back to my rant:
reinbeau said:
My one question in all of this - how can you be for self-sufficiency and also be for a big-government type like Obama, who wants to micromanage every aspect of your personal responsibility? The two just don't meet in the middle.
I don't see it as a conflict at all. I'm aiming for self-sufficiency because I want what's best for me and my family, and I think that 99% of the time, the best thing is the thing you do yourself, make at home, grow yourself, and have complete pride and ownership of. And I consider myself lucky that in my current state I'm able to pursue most of those goals, except the growing stuff part, as I don't own any land. (YET!) To those ends, I would like government to both stay out of my personal choices, and provide me and my fellow Americans the chance to pursue our loftiest goals.
In short, I believe we should have as many rights as possible, and also as much opportunity to achieve our dreams as possible. And this is why I'm proud to be liberal.
First, rights. It is clear to me that in recent years at least, the democratic party is much more interested in staying out of my private life, though neither party does as much as Id like in this arena. For instance, I want my daughter to have the right to a happy and fulfilled life if she turns out to be gay. I want the right for all prisoners to a fair trial. I support the right to own a gun, but I also want the right to walk down the street and not be afraid of getting gunned down by an Uzi, a weapon only sold for the purpose of murder and intimidation. I want the right for my wife to make decisions about her body based on her own beliefs, not the beliefs forced upon her by the government. I want the right to a private phone conversation. I want all prisoners to have the right to be treated with respect, not tortured. And so on.
And then, opportunity. I believe that we all deserve good medical treatment if we get sick, regardless of economic situation. I believe we all deserve an excellent education for our children. I believe we all deserve well-policed communities, fire departments that respond promptly, roads that dont destroy our vehicles...
This does not negate my desires for self-sufficiency. Paying taxes does not allow the government to intrude in my personal life. Im not advocating health care that forces me to go for checkups even when Im not sick (and neither is Obama) but the opportunity for that healthcare to be available regardless of my finances. I dont want the government to force me into public education, but I want that public education to be excellent if I choose to use it. I suppose along the same lines, I dont plan on using every road the government maintains, but Id like the roads to be maintained for my fellow citizens. I want our prison system to be well-maintained and strict but compassionate for those who wind up there.
And Im willing to pay taxes for all these things. Heck, Ill even go ahead and even agree with Joe Bidens mis-spoken statement that taxes are patriotic because I also believe firmly that you can judge a society by how it treats its poorest members, and I am very willing to pay taxes on my income to support my less fortunate countrymen and women, and know that such a support network will be there should the same fates ever befall me.
Again, this does not change my self-sufficiency one bit. I want the government to stay out of my rights. And I want the government to provide the opportunity for me and my family to succeed no matter what our economic situation is, but NOT to force me into anything I don't want. The only difference between you and I is that Im willing to do all that on a smaller percentage of my income, because I believe in taxation. I believe in helping out our fellow citizens with services that will allow them to pursue the same dreams Im pursuing. I believe that it is an excellent moral decision to help out those less fortunate than me with a portion of my income. But money is not the point of self-sufficiency anyway. In fact, some of my self-sufficient choices were made to enable me to pay those taxes to help out my fellow citizens, and Im happy with that.
These are not popular opinions, perhaps, but then I imagine many of us here have unpopular opinions. And there are of course other issues in my voting plans (the war in Iraq, for instance) but Ive already gone on too long. Pardon the long rant!