Thanks for all the ideas and feedback. Please know that we don't ignore ideas. We take them all into consideration and try to weigh the pros and cons... many of which are very hard to quantify, and maybe impossible to understand if you can't see what's going on in the background.
We made the decision early with BYC that it couldn't be an all things to all people forum. We got requests all the time to create a gardening section, but we knew that it would take on a life of its own, so we created TEG. We also got requests for a goat forum, horse website, cow forum, etc. etc. etc. so we created BYH.
While the decision has been made not to create more duplicate sections on the sister sites, there may or may not be a time when it is appropriate... but the staff feel that now is not the time.
We also understand that each community will have its own personality... forums are like people, they start off tiny and try to find their way. They go through some growing pains, and hopefully find their stride. Even then they will continue to change and develop, growing all along the way.
We're open to the discussion of ideas and try not to shoot any down. Again, please remember that just because we may not agree or make changes instantly doesn't mean we aren't listening, paying attention, or having discussion behind the scenes.
