I made the liquid laundry soap! Not for any particular reason, since the dry worked just fine. I just wanted to try it, since it's a bit cheaper. And fun to make! Made my own soap instead of Fels Naptha. Again, not because I didn't like the Fels. I just wanted to! And so I used 3 ounces grated 100% lard soap, 1/2 cup Borax, 1/2 cup Washing Soda, and two gallons water. A bit of orange EO, also. Mine got way past the "jello" stage, but just the top half. The rest was liquid. So I whisked it into a soupy consistency. It works great! No scent at all, just clean. Some of the shirts were very bad smelling before I washed them, from the silly heat we had, so I'm pleased.
A few days ago I had to use some Tide I had left over. Omg horrible! I must have used too much (I don't know how!) and when it was done, there was still suds on my clothes! I had to run them through again! Plus even after that, they had a STRONG perfumed smell. I had though everyone was exaggerating when they had this same story, but they're NOT. I'm giving the rest of the Tide to my mom. I have enough lard soap to last a long time.